Celebrating 25 Years as Your Hometown Jeweler – Where Columbus Gets Engaged! Voted Columbus' Best Jewelry Store in 2023 and 2024, Worthington Jewelers has helped central Ohio celebrate life’s milestones since 2000. Explore over 1,500 engagement rings and wedding bands or create a custom design with our expert jewelers. From natural and lab-grown diamonds to colorful gemstones, we offer stunning styles to match every budget. Shop birthstones, vintage and estate pieces, permanent jewelry, silver fashions, and more. We also buy, repair, and appraise jewelry, gold, and diamonds—with free cleanings and inspections! Family-owned by Bob and Theresa Capace, we offer a fun, no-pressure shopping experience that’s family- and dog-friendly.